The Ultimate Sporting City Debate Final: Detroit vs. Boston
Fifteen other cities have rose up to join our debate and have fallen by the wayside leaving only the Bean Town and the Motor City. You've heard about Boston's sporting history, rivalries, and sporting highs and lows. The same goes for Detroit's history, rivalries, and peaks/valleys. Today is the culmination of three preliminary rounds of voting, which included almost 4,000 votes spread over 17 total cities. Today, you all determine the greatest Sporting City in America. Who is the best? Voting will be open for a week.
23 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
When does MGoBlog show up?
Taking bets! Taking bets!
Better to have died a small boy than to drop this football - John HeismanFromTheRumbleSeat
by Winfield Featherston on Jul 16, 2010 8:18 AM EDT reply actions
I took Boston all along,
but I’m concerned that these winners are based on PRO cities. Neither Boston nor Detroit has a great CFB/CBB tradition excepting BC and UMichigan.
If we did a tournament of College town/cities, that would be too restricting because so many CFB/CBB towns are built around one school (Tuscaloosa, Athens, Chapel Hill and Durham, Knoxville, etc) such that a vote for a city is a vote for a Major NCAA program.
This was a great Tournament!
by DressHerInWhiteAndGold on Jul 16, 2010 8:52 AM EDT reply actions
we learned a lot during this tournament
about networking, about formatting, about seeding etc.
Thanks for the participation and look for better stuff in the upcoming months/years!
Better to have died a small boy than to drop this football - John HeismanFromTheRumbleSeat
by Winfield Featherston on Jul 16, 2010 9:42 AM EDT up reply actions
Vote Calvin Johnson!
Excuse my language, ma'am, but that damn Dodd's gonna beat my butt today. -- Bear Bryant, November 1962
Uh Oh
Detroit is blitzing this poll again. Even though my wife is from Detroit and a great sports fan even she admits now that we are in Massachusetts that their are no fans in the world like Boston fans.
by Atlanta's original team on Jul 16, 2010 11:38 AM EDT reply actions
Deep down in our hearts ...
We all know who the real ultimate sports city is … and it’s not the one with the NFL franchise that hasn’t had a winning season in 9 tries.
BC Interruption, SBN's Boston College Eagles blog
by Brian Favat on Jul 16, 2010 12:19 PM EDT up reply actions
Boston would win if...
If we were basing our evaluations on the quality of professional teams in recent years, Boston would win. The game changes when you evaluate the history, tradition, and fanbases of the areas’ professional and collegiate teams.
Oh, yeah, the heart
I’m sorry, I was busy reading all of the compelling reasons that Detroit bloggers were giving in favor of the Motor City; I forgot to search deep down in my heart. Let me check…
[Misopogon shrinks to 1/1000th size, goes on a Body Wars adventure, speaks to his inner ventricle]
Misopogon: Oh, ventricle deep down in my inner heart, what say you: is Detroit or Boston the greater sporting city?
Innner Heart: Are you the guy who has been following the Wolverines and Tigers and Red Wings and Pistons and Lions all this time?
Misopogon: Umm…yes?
Innner Heart: Fuck you.
Misopogon: Wait….what? I asked which is the better sporting city?
Innner Heart: Dude, you have no idea, what hell you’ve been putting me through.
Misopogon: I don’t….
Innner Heart: Oh, don’t even start, asshole! I’m trying to pump blood here, pump YOUR blood to YOUR vital organs and extremities, and you’re making that impossible, what with your Wolverines and Tigers experiencing the biggest highs and lows in sports history all within like a year ….omigod STOP DOING THAT!
Misopogon: Doing what?
Innner Heart: I saw that! You were just blogging about what number Mike Modano should wear as a Red Wing. Don’t think I didn’t see that!
Misopogon: Dude, would you just answer the question? Which sporting city do you think…?
Innner Heart: No. I’m not answering your stupid questions. Not so long as you keep telling your body to prepare for a Lions victory so I have to come to full stop every week when you are (gasp) let down once again! Not so long as you keep obsessing about Michigan’s defensive backfield problems, or talking “WAR” values of middle infielders on the trade market, or convincing yourself Joel Zumaya’s arm will rise once again from the grave to hurl 104 mph heaters…
Misopogon: What, like we’re the only sports fans who do this much obsessing? My brother in Boston enjoys Red Sox and Celtics and Patriots and Bruins and sometimes even BC, and that’s not even mentioning that cool Harvard/Yale thing, and his heart’s not killing him.
Innner Heart: That’s because he only pays attention WHEN THEY’RE WINNING, which is like all the time anyway. Ass.
Misopogon: Okay, so according to you, Boston is the better sporting city?
Innner Heart: Whatever, dude. Sure. Boston’s better. Because you Detroit people care WAY TOO MUCH. You have way too many important traditions, way too much history, your highs are too high, your lows are too low, and plus you’re fat, you all smoke, and don’t get me started about the officiating fuck-overs you go through: These are called RISK FACTORS, dick. Boston it’s just about winning and enjoying some quirky traditions and even if you eat a Yawkey Way frank you’re still going to walk it off when you get stoned afterwards and decide to follow those red bricks all over town. And if, say, your Original Six hockey team stops winning for a decade, you don’t start pining over a thug duo, you simply STOP CARING. This is called CARDIOVASCULAR CARE. This is important.
Misopogon: Fine. Thanks for your answer. Anything else?
Innner Heart: Fuck you.
Well, you were right.
L'Équipe! L'Équipe! L'Équipe!
Detroit needs this win badly
it may be the only one they get this year.
by Atlanta's original team on Jul 16, 2010 1:22 PM EDT up reply actions
Red Wings
I think they’re going into ‘10-’11 as the favorites right now. Chicago’s dismantling everything under the (very very good) topping, Pittsburgh is finally getting to the point where Bettman can’t hold the franchise up (i.e. they actually have to pay all of those 1st and 2nd overall draft picks). San Jose continues to be San Jose. Who else you got?
L'Équipe! L'Équipe! L'Équipe!
My heart also tells me that little Boston College has owned Michigan recently ...
Football wins last five years
- Boston College – 47 (9 + 10 + 11 + 9 + 8)
- Michigan – 35 (7 + 11 + 9 + 3 + 5)
Hockey National Championships
- Boston College – 3
- Michigan – 0
Basketball head-to-head over last nine seasons
- Boston College – 3
- Michigan – 0
Men’s Basketball wins last five years
- Boston College – 100
- Michigan – 90
BC Interruption, SBN's Boston College Eagles blog
And I have to say as one who is not a hockey fan
the Winter Classic at Fenway Park was one of the coolest sporting spectacles I have ever seen, followed up the city’s college championship. The BU vs. BC rivalry in hockey is one of the great rivalries I have seen in any sport.
by Atlanta's original team on Jul 16, 2010 2:21 PM EDT up reply actions
Can you get some Boston people on this site to vote
for heaven’s sake? I know they are real busy watching the Sox right now but come on. I have real sense of justice about these things. Being a transplanted southerner and all.
by Atlanta's original team on Jul 16, 2010 2:23 PM EDT up reply actions
To be clear
This is a hockey game I’m talking about
That is so cool
Again, as a non-hockey fan, I am impressed.
Where in Detroit will this game be played?
by Atlanta's original team on Jul 16, 2010 3:34 PM EDT up reply actions
Game will be played at Michigan Stadium
There was apparently some thought of having Michigan-MSU and the Red Wings play there in the same weekend, but unfortunately, the idea was discarded.

by 




















