3-4 Defensive Line Primer
The basic difference between one and two gap techniques is that in a one gap technique, defensive linemen are expected to penetrate a particular gap and disrupt the backfield. The two gap defensive lineman is expected to take blockers head on and defend the gaps over each of their shoulders. Here's a simple diagram illustrating a basic 4-3 line, which typically utilizes the one gap technique, versus a 3-4 utilizing two gap technique:

Now, what makes the 3-4 defensive line so fun for defensive coordinators and frustrating for offenses is the fact that a 3-4 really clogs the middle. The biggest, strongest guys are actually assigned to defending the middle of your defense. In the one gap 4-3 defense, there's a checkerboard of linebacker, lineman, linebacker, lineman, etc. assigned to defend individual gaps. In the 4-3, play-side pursuit and backside containment are primary responsibilities of big lumbering defensive linemen. Remember the Orange Bowl where drop back passer Ricky Stanzi outran D. Morgan on a QB scramble?
The 3-4 solves this problem. Smaller, faster linebackers are defending the edges of the offensive formation rather than down linemen. Now, re-imagine that situation with Philip Wheeler chasing down Ricky Stanzi. Because they're stand up position players, their increased flexibility pre-snap and ability to react post-snap gives them a huge advantage in run defense over their 4-3 counterparts (three point stance defensive ends).
The two gap technique is not all that is utilized by 3-4's. Depending on the opposing offense's tendencies, down and distance situation, and defensive coordinator, you'll see one gap technique utilized by 3-4 defenses as well. One gap defenses are typically used in blitzes and/or definite pass rush situations. Some teams, like the Pittsburgh Steelers, rely almost entirely on the one gap 3-4 because they've got smaller, more athletic linemen and really good linebackers that can cover a lot of ground. They also love to blitz.
The best example of a two gap system in recent history was the Patriots featuring nose tackle Vince Wilfork. The two gap Patriots are bigger, longer linemen capable of consuming offensive linemen allowing the Patriot 2nd and 3rd tiers to make plays.
For more information on defensive line responsibilities in the 3-4, check out SBNation's Texas A&M Blog, I am the 12th Man. They have articles tailored specifically to the strongside defensive end, nose tackle, and weakside defensive end.
7 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
2-Gapping
The biggest thing here is starting with the NT. You’ll find that he’ll have a side he prefers and what that means is if he’s most comfortable taking on the guard with his left arm he’ll play that way more often (evidenced by the tilt technique some teams use). Although the Nose if technically a 2-Gapper what he’ll be doing mostly is getting a guard (L or R) to commit to him along with his primary target, the center. For this comments purpose we’ll say your NT goes left.
At the snap it starts with your NT, he engages the center and works left to force the guard to engage him as well. The right side A-Gap becomes a “run through” for the right ILB and the left side B-Gap becomes a “run through” for the left ILB. This leaves the left DE to pinch the tackle down, closing the left side B-Gap and, when executed perfectly, creating 3 exterior defenders (DE, OLB, ILB scraping). On the right side the DE 2-gaps working to control the right side B-Gap and C-Gaps while the right OLB squeezes down the TE to give a hard edge.
Beautiful when it all works in concert. Every gap is accounted for, the DE that can collapse a B-Gap is a true gift as he, like the NT, frees up run through lanes for the LBs.
I absolutely love reading and talking about this stuff. Its outstanding. Kudos to you fellas.
Yeah BoYeeEEeeE
by InTheBleachers on Apr 7, 2010 8:30 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
Yes indeed this is great stuff
So I have just a few questions based on this analysis as well as the response above.
(1) If a defensive lineman tends to favor working to his right or left side will he cheat a little bit in his stance or will he still try to play straight up on his man?
(2) If the center and guard get a good surge against the nose tackle does that cause problems for the defense or can the backers still plug the holes pretty effectively?
(3) If it is a short yardage situation does the defense revert to something closer to a 4-3 or do they just shift to a one gap approach?
by Atlanta's original team on Apr 7, 2010 9:31 AM EDT reply actions
some answers
If you watch any of Al Groh’s highlight reels, you’ll see that they hardly ever leave the 3-4 base formation. Check out this clip from Brendan of From Old Virginia: Skip to 1:28 to see goal line stand. The defense is still in the 3-4 it’s just compacted along the line of scrimmage. And based on the clips, it looks like the defense is still running 2 gap assignments.
The other questions are a matter of discipline and individual ability. It just depends on how good your defenders are. If we are getting beat at nose tackle though, I don’t think it’ll matter how good our linebackers are.
If the Ramblin' Reck burns the nationwide average of 1.61 gallons/day, it produces 14 kg of CO2 equivalent per day. 14 kg/day is less greenhouse gas emissions than those produced by a single cow or horse. There is a proverbial herd of mascots in I-A football that are more polluting than the Ramblin' Reck...
of course, as you see in that clip, it didn’t work. But Groh’s preference for beefy linemen and large linebackers helps on the goal line.
To answer this:
(2) If the center and guard get a good surge against the nose tackle does that cause problems for the defense or can the backers still plug the holes pretty effectively?
YES. To the former. Groh tends to sacrifice athleticism and size at the ILB positions for high football IQ. So if there’s a good surge, they’re often going to get surged as well. Poor nose tackle play often allows a guard to release to the second level and get a helmet on the backers, and no matter what, even if the backers play it perfectly, there’s that delay that allows the running back to break past the line of scrimmage and run downhill for four or five yards. Unless the backers crash the line immediately, as on a run blitz, and then the middle of the field is open for the slots and TEs.
I’m sure GT fans are familiar with what happens if you consistently allow four or five yards on run plays and can’t stuff the run game at the line of scrimmage.
You MUST have an NT that can hold his ground, even and especially against a double-team. Must. Not negotiable.
by MaizeAndBlueWahoo on Apr 7, 2010 1:49 PM EDT up reply actions
He May Tilt
He might tilt, or be slightly angled in his stance, it can both allow him to push through the center to the guard as well as force the guard to commit to him pre-snap.
Regarding a surge the NT’s are generally taugh to go down rather than give ground. If the NT is pushed off the ball by a center-guard combo he then impedes the flow of the ILBs and creates more running lanes. Thus, they’re taught to go down, bringing the C/G down with them and create a pile in the middle, similar to what you see on goalline from DTs.
Short yardage, depending on the personnel grouping the offense has in the team will either go “goalline” (normally a 5-2 or 6-2 to combat a jumbo package) or they’ll cut distance and play the 3-4. Play more 1-gap type techniques, NT will swallow left-A, ILB aligns and floods right-A and so on and so forth filling each gap to stop the run at the line. In short yardage there’s less time to flow for the LBs; hence why, when watching the Steelers, you’ll see Troy Polumalu scraping over the top and making short yardage stops after the DL and LBs plug all holes.
Yeah BoYeeEEeeE
by InTheBleachers on Apr 7, 2010 9:57 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
I'm not a fan of two-gapping
I’d rather bring the SS into the box, create an 8-man front, and let everyone be aggressive and play one-gap. I’m a fan of aggression.
Of course, this assumes you have at least one shotdown corner, so you can bracket the other WR with the FS and CB, thus allowing you to bring 8 to stop the run.

by 














